The business model, out loud

"If it's AGPL, why does the mobile app cost money?"

18 September 2026 · Alexander Mäule

That question arrives in some form on most sales conversations. Sometimes politely, "help me understand the licensing model", sometimes as a challenge: the app is AGPL and free, so charging €8 a year for the mobile app looks like a contradiction, or worse, a trick.

It isn't a trick. It's an answer to where the work actually goes, and since it's easier to show than to argue, here's the accounting.

What the web app costs us to build

A Nextcloud web app is PHP and Vue living inside a platform that already exists. Nextcloud handles users, groups, authentication, the app store, updates, notifications and the entire database layer. We build on top of all of that.

That reuse is why our apps can stay small and single-purpose instead of shipping their own user management, their own login screens, their own backup stories. It's also why publishing them under AGPL is sustainable, the platform carries the undifferentiated weight, and the code that's left is small enough to audit in an afternoon, which for apps that touch time records and rosters is the point rather than a footnote.

What the companions cost us to build

The mobile and terminal apps are a different ledger. A native Android app. An iOS app. A terminal that runs in kiosk mode on a wall-mounted tablet. An offline queue that survives a dead battery and a dead network. Licence verification that works without phoning home every hour.

None of that rides on Nextcloud. Each companion is a separate codebase, a separate store review, a separate round of device testing, and a separate breakage every time Google or Apple changes platform rules, which they do on a schedule that doesn't consult us. There is no shared platform to amortise that work against. It costs what it costs, per platform, forever.

So the line is drawn where the work is

Server apps: AGPL, free, unlimited seats, no expiry. That stays.

Companions: annual organisation licences, flat prices with low floors, so a five-person club pays €30-50 a year rather than enterprise rates. You buy seats, not downloads, the mobile app itself is a free install that activates once your organisation enters a licence key on its own Nextcloud.

Notice what the licence doesn't do: it doesn't gate the web app, it doesn't expire the AGPL code, it doesn't move your data anywhere. It pays for the thing that actually costs platform-specific work, and for the person who fixes it the week Android decides foreground services work differently now.

Why not charge for everything, then?

Because the free web app is also the best sales argument we have, and I say that without embarrassment. An admin can install ArbeitszeitCheck on a test instance on Friday afternoon, try it over the weekend with real colleagues, and know by Monday whether it fits. No sales call to schedule, no trial period counting down, no demo tier with the useful parts amputated.

The companion licence becomes relevant only when the team decides it wants official mobile access, and by then the value has already been proven on their own data. If they never decide that, the web app keeps running. This is not a freemium funnel with a timer. The AGPL doesn't expire.

The answer to the email: we charge where the work is, we do not charge where the platform already did the work, and the free thing stays free in a way you can verify rather than trust.