Explainer · TourCheck
How proof works on a guard tour: QR, NFC, GPS and the fallback
"The guard was there" can be proven several ways, and they are not equal. TourCheck supports five capture methods, each with a different strength of evidence and a different way it can fail. Here is what each one actually proves.
QR scan: the workhorse
A printed QR code at the checkpoint, scanned with the companion app. Cheap to deploy (paper and a printer), unambiguous about where the guard stood, and works in dead zones where GPS never will. Its weakness is the medium: a QR code is a picture, and a picture can be photographed and scanned elsewhere. For most indoor tours the risk is theoretical; for high-assurance sites, QR pairs with NFC or geo checks rather than standing alone.
NFC: the quiet upgrade
An NFC tag costs more than paper but cannot be photocopied, the guard's phone must physically touch the tag. Same dead-zone tolerance as QR (the tag itself is offline by nature), stronger evidence that the device was present. It is the right default for permanent checkpoints that matter.
GPS geofence: no hardware, real limits
A geo checkpoint has no physical tag at all: the phone reports a position fix and the server checks it falls inside the configured radius. Zero installation cost and the only option where mounting tags is impossible, but the fix must exist. Underground car parks, stairwells, and shielded plant rooms produce exactly the situations where GPS fails, which is why a geo checkpoint in TourCheck is a distinct checkpoint kind, not a setting on a tag.
BLE beacon: proximity without touching
A small beacon broadcasts a UUID; the phone attests it heard the configured beacon at close range. No scan gesture needed, works indoors, stronger than QR because the beacon's identity is live radio, not a printable image. Cost: hardware plus batteries plus someone who replaces them.
Attested: the fifth option
Sometimes proof degrades honestly: no GPS fix inside a concrete plant room, a dead beacon battery, a tag someone painted over. TourCheck's answer is not a fake confirmation but a weak-evidence channel: the guard confirms with a bound site photo, and the event is journaled as an attestation, confirmed, but graded separately in the record. Planners see "attested" rather than "scanned" because a photo of the machine hall is real evidence, just weaker evidence, and pretending it equals a tag scan would corrupt the whole point of grading evidence at all.
Choosing per checkpoint, not per site
The useful mental model: QR for volume, NFC for the checkpoints that matter, geofence where nothing can be mounted, beacon where hands-free confirmation pays, and attestation as the channel that keeps "couldn't prove it" from becoming "didn't do it." A round in TourCheck mixes all five freely, the evidence grade travels with each event into the same hash-chained journal, which is what makes the weakest method still worth recording.