Engineering

Fourteen small apps, one stack

12 November 2026 · Software by Design

We sell a suite, but we don't ship one. The Check family is fourteen separate Nextcloud apps, each installable on its own, each useful on its own. That was a deliberate choice, and it costs us a convenience most suite vendors enjoy: we can't assume anything about what else you run.

What "modular" actually commits us to

Each app must stand alone, a team running only DutyCheck gets a complete roster tool, not a nag screen for ArbeitszeitCheck. Sibling apps exchange information only when both are installed and enabled. And data stays on your instance: when ArbeitszeitCheck tells DutyCheck that someone is on approved leave, that read happens inside your Nextcloud database, not through our servers, we never see it, because there is nothing of ours in the path to see it with.

The boundary problem nobody markets

Modularity gets tested at the seams. A recent example: ArbeitszeitCheck 1.9 added absence types, child-sick leave, overtime compensation, and a namespace for custom types an organisation invents itself. DutyCheck reads those absences to keep the roster honest. What should it do with a type it has never heard of?

Two answers were possible. Treat unknown types as "probably working" and roster the person, tidy for the planner, wrong for the duty. Or treat them as blocking, which occasionally flags someone who could have worked, but never silently assigns someone who is absent. We chose the second: over-blocking is a visible conflict the planner can resolve in a minute; under-blocking is an invisible gap that shows up as an empty post on a Sunday.

None of this is glamorous. It is also exactly the kind of decision a monolith never has to make, because in a monolith, the boundary is someone else's problem by definition.

What you can take from it

If you evaluate suites, ask one question: which parts stop working when you remove a piece? If uninstalling the invoicing module breaks the time tracker, you bought a monolith with a modular price list. Our answer is on the Solutions page: install only what you need, and every module stands alone.