Comparison · Maintenance
A MaintainX alternative, assessed
MaintainX is the market's polished CMMS: per-user pricing, mobile-first, thousands of reviews. MaintenanceCheck is a Nextcloud app from a three-person studio. These are not the same product at different prices, they are different bets. Here is which bet suits which organisation.
What MaintainX charges, as of November 2026
From their public pricing page (checked 2026-11, prices move, verify before you sign): Essential around $20-25 per user per month, Premium $65-75 per user per month. Requesters, people who only file tickets, are free, which is a genuinely good design choice.
| 20 users · technicians + planners | MaintainX | MaintenanceCheck |
|---|---|---|
| Licence | $20-25/user/month Essential ($4,800-6,000/yr) | Web app: €0 (AGPL). Mobile seats: €8/seat/year, €40 floor |
| Platform | Included, their cloud | You run Nextcloud (or pay a host ≈€10-30/mo) |
| Data | On their infrastructure | On your server, your database |
| Exit | Export, then the account closes | Your database was always yours |
The 3-year number for 20 users: MaintainX Essential ≈ $14,400-18,000. MaintenanceCheck with managed Nextcloud ≈ €600-1,600 depending on mobile seats and hosting. That gap is real. So is what it buys.
Where MaintainX wins: take this seriously
- Polish and onboarding. MaintainX has a design team larger than our company. Their mobile UX, tutorials, and rollout materials are better. If technician adoption is your biggest fear, that matters more than any price table.
- Zero infrastructure. No server, no updates, no admin. If nobody in your organisation can or will own a Nextcloud, per-seat SaaS is the honest answer, not self-hosting.
- Ecosystem. Integrations, parts inventory depth, metering, a marketplace. MaintenanceCheck covers work orders, assets, schedules and the service report, it does not pretend to be a 1:1 feature clone.
Where MaintenanceCheck fits instead
- You already run Nextcloud. Then the marginal cost of maintenance management is one app install and, for technicians in the field, €8 per seat per year for the mobile companion. The TCO argument is not close.
- Data residency is a requirement, not a preference. Public bodies, works-council environments, healthcare-adjacent operations: work orders contain names, schedules, locations, and photos. On your server, they never leave the building.
- You want the exit to be boring. AGPL code, plain database tables, exports that do not need a goodwill request. If MaintenanceCheck ever stops fitting, your data is already where you can read it.
The one-line version
MaintainX if you want the best-packaged CMMS and accept per-seat SaaS pricing on someone else's infrastructure. MaintenanceCheck if you run, or are willing to run, Nextcloud, and your buying criteria start with data sovereignty and a licence bill that does not scale with headcount.
Prices and features as documented in November 2026; verify both vendors' current terms before deciding.