Comparison · Worked example

Three years, twenty people, real money

Per-seat SaaS against self-hosted Nextcloud, added up the way an invoice would be, server included, the admin time nobody bills included, and the spots where the cloud number genuinely wins. Competitor prices from public pricing pages, checked November 2026.

The setup

Twenty employees need time tracking. That's the question we get asked most often, and it has three answers depending on who's holding the server.

Line itemCloud SaaS (per seat)Nextcloud + ArbeitszeitCheck
Software, 3 yrs≈ €7.60/seat/mo entry tier × 20 × 36 = €5,472Web app €0 (AGPL). Companions €8 × 20 × 3 = €480
Server, 3 yrsInside the seat price.Existing Nextcloud: €0 marginal · managed hosting ≈ €10/mo ≈ €360 · own VPS €5-10/mo plus admin time
Admin timeVendor owns ops, updates, backups, 3 a.m. incidents.Yours or your hoster's: updates, backups, restores. Real work, counted, but work that serves every other app on the same instance too.
ExitExport the data, lose the system; history ends with the subscription.Data already sits in your database; the apps are AGPL and forkable; uninstall cleans the tables, export first.
Total, 3 yrs≈ €5,472 before seat 21 or a tier change.≈ €480-840 in licences and hosting, plus the admin time you carry or outsource.

One more line: a Check Partner support package (Standard: 10 hours for €1,190/yr) adds €3,570 across three years and still lands below the cloud total, that's the "someone picks up when it breaks" option if you don't want to carry ops alone.

Where this maths can still be wrong for you

Three failure modes, in order of how often they actually happen:

  • Nobody owns the server. Not even a managed one. Paying €5,472 to never think about updates beats €840 of infrastructure nobody maintains, unmaintained fails quietly and at the worst time.
  • You needed the suite, not the feature. If the seat price buys onboarding, org charts and performance reviews and you use them, comparing it to a time-tracking line item is our marketing error, not yours.
  • You're about to be fifty seats, not twenty. Per-seat SaaS scales predictably; a self-hosted stack needs someone to scale it.

Where the self-hosted number holds

  • Nextcloud already runs, the marginal software cost really is €480 over three years.
  • You run several Check apps on one instance: DutyCheck, InventoryCheck and MaintenanceCheck companions at €6-8/seat/yr still land under a single mid-tier SaaS seat combined.
  • Data residency is a requirement, not a preference, "our own server" settles procurement questions that a subprocessor list doesn't.

Every price on this page is a real number we publish or verified publicly. Order page for licences, support packages for humans.