The maths

What self-hosted actually costs

2 September 2026 · Alexander Mäule

Last month a quote request came in that ended with a line I keep thinking about: "Your app is free and Clockify costs us about €90 a month. What's the catch?"

There is a catch. It's just not in the software, it's in the sentence "your app is free." The app is free. The thing it runs on is not, and pretending otherwise is how self-hosted comparisons end up being as dishonest as the SaaS ones they mock.

So here is the invoice that never gets written, for a twenty-person team over three years. Three versions of it, because "self-hosted" describes three different realities.

Version one: you already run Nextcloud

ItemCost over 3 years
ArbeitszeitCheck web app (AGPL, unlimited seats)€0
Mobile companion licences, 20 seats × €8/yr€480
Extra server capacity for one more Nextcloud app€0 (it rides along)
Extra admin work for one more Nextcloud app≈ nothing on top of the updates you already run
Total€480

This is the scenario the suite is built for, and it is almost embarrassingly good. The marginal cost of a fifth app on an instance that already exists is the licence fee and nothing else.

Version two: you rent a managed Nextcloud

ItemCost over 3 years
ArbeitszeitCheck web app€0
Mobile companion licences, 20 seats€480
Managed Nextcloud, small instance, ~€10/month~€360
Total~€840

The hoster patches, backs up and answers at 3 a.m. You click update and pay two invoices a year. This is the version I recommend to organisations that want self-hosted data residency without wanting a server hobby.

Version three: you run your own VPS

ItemCost over 3 years
ArbeitszeitCheck web app€0
Mobile companion licences, 20 seats€480
VPS, €5-10/month€180-360
Admin time: updates, backups, restores, the evening Nextcloud 32 breaks somethingYour call. Seriously, put a number here.
Total€660-840 + your evenings

The cheapest row on paper and the most expensive in attention. Some organisations have an admin who'd be doing this anyway, and for them it genuinely is cheapest. Some discover the "admin who'd be doing this anyway" is one person, and that person just quit.

And the other column

Same twenty people on a per-seat SaaS time tracker. The published entry price of one well-known HR suite sits around €7.60 per employee per month. That's €152 a month, €5,472 over the same three years, before seat 21, before the tier that holds the feature you actually need, before the annual "we've adjusted our pricing" email.

That number is not a rip-off, and I won't pretend it is. Hosting, ops, updates, backups and someone accountable at 3 a.m. are all inside it. In the €480-840 scenarios those things are your problem or your hoster's line item. The €5,472 buys them off your desk entirely.

The part I can't put in a table

Every self-hosted comparison I've read, including, I'm sure, some on this site, makes one of two dodges. Either the server vanishes ("the software is free!") or the admin vanishes ("my colleague just handles it"). The first dodge undercounts money; the second undercounts the person.

The version: if nobody in your organisation wants to own a server, even a managed one, where "owning" means paying a hosting invoice and clicking update, then the €5,472 column is the cheaper reality and you should buy it. I'd rather lose that sale than watch someone buy the wrong architecture and find out in month nine that unmaintained infrastructure fails silently.

If Nextcloud is already running in your building or at your hoster, the answer is the €480 column and it's not close. That's not marketing arithmetic, it's what the quote request above actually came back to.

The full three-year comparison has the same maths with both columns side by side, including the rows where the cloud number wins.