Comparison · Time tracking
A self-hosted alternative to Clockify
Clockify made its name on a generous free tier and a polished timer. ArbeitszeitCheck makes its case on German labour law, data sovereignty, and running inside your own Nextcloud. Different products wearing similar labels, here is how to choose.
The short version
Clockify is a general-purpose SaaS time tracker: projects, billable hours, reports, a free tier that covers basic tracking and paid tiers for admin features. It is good at what it does. What it does not do is run on your infrastructure or implement Arbeitszeitgesetz rules, break enforcement, rest periods, monthly locks, as product behaviour rather than policy you must enforce yourself.
Where Clockify is the better answer
- Agency billing workflows. If your core question is "which client pays for these hours", Clockify's project-billable model is built for exactly that. ArbeitszeitCheck tracks working time for compliance and payroll, not for invoicing clients.
- Zero-admin start. Sign up, invite, done. No server. If you have no Nextcloud and no appetite for one, the free tier beats any self-hosted setup cost.
- Integrations. Clockify connects to a large ecosystem of PM and payroll tools out of the box.
Where ArbeitszeitCheck fits instead
- German labour-law environments. Break rules, rest-time checks, monthly closures with frozen snapshots, DATEV export, implemented in the app, auditable in the changelog, not bolted on as a policy document.
- Works-council settings. When the Betriebsrat asks where the raw time data lives, "our own server, in our own datacenter" ends the conversation. Append-only audit trails and month locks give the council something concrete to inspect.
- Headcount-independent pricing. The web app is AGPL, free, self-hosted. Only the mobile companion and terminal licences are paid (€8/seat/year, €40 floor, published). At 50 people, that is not a rounding difference against per-seat SaaS over three years.
The real cost comparison
Free-tier Clockify genuinely costs €0, until you need approvals, locks, or admin controls, which is where the paid tiers start (per user per month, check their current pricing). Self-hosted ArbeitszeitCheck costs no licence fee for the web app but needs a Nextcloud: roughly €10-30/month managed, or real admin hours on your own infrastructure. We wrote the maths in the three-year total-cost comparison, including the scenarios where the SaaS wins.
Decide on the binding constraint
If the constraint is "we need billable-hour tracking for client invoicing", that is Clockify's home turf. If the constraint is "works council requires the data on our own infrastructure and German labour law enforced by the software", that is ours. Both are reasonable products; they just answer different questions.