Comparison · Decision guide
Who should actually buy a CMMS: and who shouldn't
MaintainX and UpKeep are built for maintenance departments with maintenance budgets. MaintenanceCheck is built for teams whose maintenance lives inside Nextcloud. Prices verified on the vendors' public pricing pages, November 2026.
Buy MaintainX or UpKeep if…
- Your preventive maintenance runs on meters and sensors. Counter-based scheduling is CMMS territory; ours is a due-date board with work orders.
- Spare parts and purchasing belong in the same tool. MaintenanceCheck has no procurement module and won't grow one this year.
- Your technicians will never open a browser. Their mobile apps are genuinely good and mobile-first; ours is a licensed companion to a web app.
- You have a maintenance department, not a maintenance list. Asset hierarchies, lifecycle tracking, multi-site analytics, if that's your problem, that's their product, and it's priced like it: MaintainX Essential $20/user/mo annually ($25 monthly), Premium $65/$75; UpKeep $24 Essential, $55 Premium. Requester seats are free on both, which helps, but ten paying technicians still run $2,400-6,600 a year.
We're not being modest here. They're competent products. If your maintenance needs their depth, buy one of them and this page has done its job.
MaintenanceCheck fits if…
- Nextcloud already runs in your organisation. Adding work orders costs a few clicks plus at most €8/seat/yr for field companions, the app itself is €0, AGPL, from the Nextcloud App Store.
- Your "maintenance department" is two people and a list of machines. A full CMMS is scaffolding for a team you don't have. Due-date board, work orders, checklists, photos, that is the shape, deliberately.
- The audit matters more than the analytics. Servicebericht PDFs and evidence living on your Nextcloud beat a dashboard nobody exports. The Prüfnachweis PDF says on it that it's an operational record, not a legal certificate, your regulator decides whether that's enough, not us.
- The budget is real. Ten technicians on cloud CMMS is $2,400+ a year. The same field team on companions is €80/year, plus the Nextcloud you already run, or managed hosting if you don't.
The facts, side by side
| Cloud CMMS (MaintainX, UpKeep) | MaintenanceCheck on Nextcloud | |
|---|---|---|
| Price model | Per paying user per month (see above). Ten paying technicians ≈ $2,400-6,600/yr. | Web app €0 (AGPL). Optional mobile companion €8/seat/yr, €40 floor. The Nextcloud behind it is not in that number, free only if you already run one. |
| Scope | Full CMMS: asset hierarchy, meter-based PM, parts stock, purchasing, analytics. | Due-date board, work orders, checklists, photos, Servicebericht PDFs. No asset lifecycle, no procurement. |
| Data lives | Vendor cloud (both hosted in the US; jurisdiction per their terms). | Your Nextcloud database, on infrastructure you choose. |
| Evidence | Signature capture, in-app history. | Prüfnachweis PDF as an operational record, marked as such, not as a legal certificate. |
MaintenanceCheck product page, installable free from the Nextcloud App Store; companions priced on the order page.