Comparison
Time tracking: cloud suite or your own Nextcloud?
Personio, Clockify and similar cloud tools vs. ArbeitszeitCheck on your own instance, compared on price model, data custody, and what happens when you leave. Competitor prices checked on their public pages, November 2026.
Where they genuinely differ
| Cloud suites (Personio, Clockify…) | ArbeitszeitCheck on Nextcloud | |
|---|---|---|
| Price model | Per employee per month, Personio entry tier lists ≈ €7.60/employee/month, billed per seat while you use it. | Web app: €0 (AGPL). Optional mobile/terminal companions: annual licence per organisation, ArbeitszeitCheck companion is €8/seat/year with a €40 floor. The Nextcloud itself is not in that number, free only if you already run one; otherwise managed hosting or admin time costs real money. |
| Where the data is | Vendor cloud; jurisdiction follows their terms. | Your Nextcloud database, on infrastructure you choose. |
| Operations | Vendor runs everything. | You (or your host) run Nextcloud. That is real work. |
| Code | Proprietary. | AGPL-3.0-or-later, readable, auditable, forkable. |
| Exit | Export then close account; formats vary. | Your database never left your hands. |
When the cloud suite wins honestly
- You need payroll, recruiting, and time tracking in one product, ArbeitszeitCheck does not do payroll.
- Nobody can or will run a Nextcloud, even a managed one.
- Per-seat pricing is fine because your team is small and your needs are generic.
Personio is a broader HR suite; Clockify is a focused tracker with a generous free tier. Both are respectable products. This comparison is about price model and custody, not about calling them worse.
When self-hosted wins honestly
- You already run Nextcloud, the marginal cost of adding time tracking is near zero.
- Data protection requires identifiable infrastructure, not a sub-processor list.
- You need working-time rules that can be audited, our policy-layer design exists precisely for this.