Engineering

Labour law is not a settings page

12 November 2026 · Software by Design

Every time-tracking vendor claims compliance somewhere on their website. Usually it means a dropdown where you pick a country and a checkbox that says you read the terms. When we built the break and working-time rules for ArbeitszeitCheck, we decided early that "compliance" had to mean something checkable in code, or it meant nothing.

Three things that look like one thing

A break rule in a German workplace is never just a break rule. There is the statutory floor, the ArbZG tiers that apply to everyone. There is the organisation's own policy, which may be stricter but must never be weaker. And there is the individual contract: the part-time parent, the alternating-shift nurse, the employee whose schedule fits no template in the system.

Most tools collapse these into one settings screen. We keep them as three layers that resolve in order. Statutory tiers are the floor and they block: an entry that breaks the law cannot be saved quietly. Organisation policy sits on top and warns: a shift that undercuts your own break rule produces a visible flag, not a silent rejection, because it is your rule, and your HR may have a documented reason. Personal working-time models handle the contracts that fit no shared template, scoped to one employee and inheriting the full rule set: weekday schedules, presence windows, break and overtime rules.

The technical detail that makes this work is boring on purpose: every path that writes a time entry, manual entry, correction, clock-out, mobile replay, kiosk stamp, background jobs, resolves through one policy object. There is no second copy of the logic that could disagree with the first.

What we refused to automate

Two decisions were easy to make and are worth saying out loud:

  • No location tracking. Working-time law does not require knowing where someone is, so the app does not ask. Presence rules check whether time was worked, not where.
  • No legal advice dressed as features. The DE/AT/CH working-time profiles are versioned technical reference profiles, ArbZG, AZG, ArG rule sets encoded as configuration. They are disabled by default, they are labelled as not legal advice, and an AGPL licence does not turn them into a legal review. If your works council needs a binding interpretation, that is a lawyer's job, not ours.

Why this matters when you buy

When a vendor says "compliant", ask which of the three layers their product can express. If the answer is "you configure the rules yourself", the compliance burden moved from their product to your HR desk. If the answer is "our AI handles it", ask what happens the day the auditor wants the rule that was actually applied, in writing.

ArbeitszeitCheck is free, AGPL-3.0-or-later, and the rule layers described here ship in the released versions on the App Store.